Showing posts with label VEGETARIANISM. Show all posts
Showing posts with label VEGETARIANISM. Show all posts

Monday, 30 May 2022

AATITUDE TO ANIMALS

Animal free now - the big top circus tent


The only thing on at the theatre was Murder on the Orient Express, which I had seen twice at the cinema so I knew what happened. Agatha Christie works better if you do not know whodunnit so, despite having the excellent Henry Goodman as Poirot, I gave it a miss and decided to go to the circus instead. I like to go to a live performance about once a week; it was just a short walk away and so I coughed up my twelve pounds and went along.

 

The last time I had been to see a circus must have been over half a century ago and my memory of it is inevitably hazy. What had changed in the meantime was our attitude to animals. Today it is considered unacceptable to exploit animals by using them in circuses where they perform for the public who gawp at the way they do human things and seem to threaten the lives of performers who put their heads into the mouth of a lion or tiger. 

 

It is certainly hard to argue in favour of animal cruelty and there is definitely something exploitative and undignified about elephants on tiptoe, which has now ended, leaving the human performers to keep the circus going without any help from animals. Before we celebrate, however, I want to know what happened to those animals who were released from the humiliation of performing in public. Did they just end up being sent to the abattoir? 

 

In our haste to free these same animals from performing in public, are we in effect abolishing them altogether? I have the same reservations about vegetarianism. We are often told that eating animals is an “inefficient” way of using the land and we could certainly feed a bigger population if we adopted a vegetarian – and eventually a vegan – diet. But this cutting out the middle man (or creature) must result in more people and less animals. Is that what we want?

 

Societies that adopt vegetarianism tend to be ones which are densely populated – India, Ireland in the period leading up to the potato famine, when the population was well above what it is today (eight million as opposed to six million) and, controversially, Nazi Germany. Of course, the Nazis did not give up meat universally but I am convinced that Hitler, who adopted a vegetarian lifestyle, considered a meatless world an essential part of lebensraum.

 

This literally means “living space” and was how he envisaged a future for a Germanic people who would dominate the world and eliminate all the unnecessary and inferior peoples – Slavs, the disabled, homosexuals, gypsies and Jews – who were occupying space that would be used by pure Aryan stock. Animals would eventually follow these people into oblivion. The difference between Hitler and a sentimental vegetarian is that he was honest about it.

 

My own daughter and several others in my family are vegetarians and my brother and his wife are moving towards a vegan lifestyle now. I do not love them any the less because I disagree with their choices – and I certainly think that we eat too much meat in our society – but I wonder what the future is for animals once we cease to eat them. Vegetarian societies certainly do not seem to be ones in which animals and humans live in peaceful harmony.

 

It is a long way from Nazi Germany to a visit to a modern circus which has to manage now without animals. The human performers certainly gave it a go. They performed magic and acrobatic tricks, made jokes, brought in a clown who encouraged the many children in the audience into making lots of noise. The ringmaster gamely played his part but I had the feeling that something was missing and that was the non-human element in the event.


A similar thing happened on a smaller scale on a visit to Osborne House on the Isle of Wight recently. I had been looking forward to see the horse and carriage that took us down to the Swiss Cottage but this had been replaced with a minibus. The new vehicle is quicker, more efficient and cheaper than a horse-drawn carriage but what has happened to the horses meanwhile? They have been abolished and another small step in human control is taken.

 

When – eventually – we decided to abolish slavery it was necessary for former slaves, who had previously been considered the property of their white owners, to find a new role as freed people. It would be stupid to say that this has been plain sailing since then but enough black people have prospered, such as politicians like Barack Obama and sportsmen and singers like Marcus Rashford and Aretha Franklin, to show that such a thing is at least possible.

 

There does not seem to be such a hope for animals who are destined for a one-way trip to the abattoir once they do not have a role either entertaining or being eaten by humans. This is the fundamental difference between racism and what is known as speciesism, the belief that some species are inevitably superior to others. It is up to those who refuse to eat or be entertained by animals to find a role for them that allows them to survive and even prosper.

 

There is precious little sign of that happening at present. While the short, cramped and uncomfortable life of a battery chicken may not be worth preserving, that of the performing animal might have been kept going if we had not been so absolutist in wanting to abolish all trace of it. It takes a lot of time, money and effort to feed and care for a large animal and there is little likelihood that anyone will do this if there is no economic reason for it.  

 

So what happened to the animals that used to perform in the circus or take the children on a carriage ride? Put down I bet, for the sake of a misplaced compassion. That is just another way humans have found of dominating the planet for themselves.


My other blog is diaryofatouristguide.blogspot.com


Edwin Lerner

 

Monday, 29 April 2019

A VEGGIE LENT

... and Hitler
The world's two most famous vegetarians - Gandhi





















I had my first taste of meat for six and a half weeks on the evening of Easter Saturday when Lent came to an end.  It is good to give up because starting again makes you look at what you eat/use/do afresh.  My daughter is a vegetarian, was once a vegan and has been trying to convert me without much success.  Although I do have cut back on eating meat considerably, I have not it given up. Why not?
There are three ways to approach an issue like this – intellectually, emotionally and sensually or, if you prefer, via the head, the heart and the stomach. Let’s take them one by one.
Stomach – there is no doubt that I like eating meat. Tearing flesh from bone is a very neolithic urge and an enjoyable action. After finishing a meal with meat, I feel satisfied in a way that I never quite am with its vegetarian equivalent. And there is nothing quite like the smell of roasting meat to make the taste buds salivate. This is not a moral point but, as a biological being, I am definitely up for eating my fellow residents on planet Earth. This is how I was designed – or evolved – and is not in itself a cause for regret or shame.
Heart – I am not someone who takes delight in killing fellow creatures for food. I do not hunt and am, like most city dwellers, squeamish about killing animals. If I had to kill what I ate I might need to turn vegetarian. Or maybe not.
Brain – My basic problem with vegetarianism is that if you deny the death, you deny the life. While I acknowledge that the meat industry does some pretty terrible things to animals, most of these are during their lifetimes and can be controlled, supervised, improved. If we simply abolish eating meat altogether then the animals that provide this meat will soon disappear in a one way journey to the slaughterhouse.
So, it is two out of three. I enjoy meat and am not convinced by the case for refraining from it, even if I leave the killing to some less sensitive souls.  There is nothing unusual in this: I pay someone else to fix my car - and my body - when they go wrong. On the same way they pay if they want a tourist guide. We live in a world of specialists rather than survivors and animal slaughter is definitely a specialism. Even those who shoot birds and game employ a small army of helpers who depend on the sport of the better off.
Human beings can, of course, survive on a non-meat diet and many societies have done so. It is worth pausing, however, to look at those which have and I have three examples which I believe prove my point. These three examples are one that has survived and prospered, one that has ended and one that, thank God, never came into being. They are India, pre-famine Ireland and Hitler’s vision of a future Germany.
India is a country where the majority of the population have never eaten meat. It is not illegal to do so but it is restricted to the wealthier sections of society. In fact, meat-eating is often seen as a sign that you have risen from the ranks of the peasantry who cannot afford meat. Few Indians argue in favour of vegetarianism from a moral standpoint. They have just excised it from their way of living over the centuries. It is well known that you can feed more people per unit of land with a vegetarian diet than by raising animals, so this is how the Indians have coped with such a large population in a restricted space. Likewise, vegetarianism is often adopted in the West by people who live in densely crowded countries. Those who occupy places with wide open spaces almost always eat meat – either through hunting or by raising livestock.
Ireland today it has a population of five to six million which is actually lower than it was 200 years ago when it had to feed around eight million people. The reason for the drop in numbers was the potato famine which killed a million and forced over a million more people to emigrate. The Irish pre-famine diet consisted largely of potatoes and when the crop failed, hunger inevitably followed. Again, there was nothing particularly moral about this adoption of a meatless life. It was simply a result a large population in a restricted area. Once the population dropped the Irish starting eating meat again and still (mostly) do so.
Nazi Germany was formed, of course, from the vision of one man, Adolf Hitler. The extent of and the reasons for Hitler’s adoption of a meatless diet are debatable but it seems to me that mass vegetarianism was an essential consequence of ‘lebensraum’, literally ‘living space’ whereby the Aryan races would expand by seizing land from their weaker neighbours. The accompanying race purification would mean getting rid of undesirables – Jews, homosexuals, gypsies and those mentally or physically disabled – and animals would follow them into extinction as living space was increased both inwardly by more efficient land use coupled with eugenics and outwardly by conquest of those unfortunate enough to live next to the Nazis. The world’s two most famous vegetarians were Hitler and Gandhi. They were superficially opposites yet they both wanted to free their people and feed them in a restricted space.  Coincidence? I doubt it.
Hang on a moment here.  Are we saying that all vegetarians are fascists? Of course not. They are usually gentle and humane, inclined to be left-wing. Yet, the vegetarian movement is surely one which increases human domination of the planet rather than one which allows animals and human beings to live in Disneyesque harmony. It is an evolutionary defence mechanism designed to help us survive as our population increases. And for that reason – rather than sentiment or taste preference – I cannot take it up. 
Edwin Lerner